Skip to the main content

8 min readPublished Last updated

CASL-Compliant Email Sign-Up Forms, Explained

Written by UXPro Design Studio. Kitchener, ON. Prepared with AI assistance and checked against the sources listed below. General information, not legal advice.

What makes an email sign-up form CASL-compliant?

A CASL-compliant sign-up form asks for consent through an action the visitor takes themselves, such as ticking an empty box. It says what you will send and who is sending, gives your contact details, and says people can unsubscribe at any time. Then you keep a record of each sign-up, because the sender has to prove consent.

Example, not a client

Redlined example

A typical small-business newsletter sign-up box
  1. Consent box

    Struck: [x] Keep me updated (ticked by default). Inserted: [ ] Yes, send me our monthly newsletter with new products and offers. (Unticked.)

  2. Under the box

    [Business name], [mailing address] · [email address]

  3. Withdrawal line

    You can unsubscribe at any time with the link in every email.

Invented from patterns that recur across many sites. No real business is depicted; any resemblance is the pattern, not the firm.
Key facts
The lawCanada's Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL), S.C. 2010, c. 23, with the CRTC's Electronic Commerce Protection Regulations
The core ruleNo commercial electronic message without the recipient's express or implied consent, sender identification and an unsubscribe mechanism (s.6)
What the form must showThe purpose, your business name, a mailing address plus a phone number answered by a person or voicemail, an email address or a web address, and a statement that consent can be withdrawn
How long consent lastsExpress: until withdrawn. Implied: 2 years after a purchase, 6 months after an inquiry (s.10(10))
Who has to prove consentThe sender (s.13), so keep a record of every sign-up

What does CASL require before you send marketing email?

Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL) prohibits sending a commercial electronic message (CEM) to an electronic address unless the recipient has consented, expressly or impliedly, and the message identifies the sender, gives contact information and includes an unsubscribe mechanism (CASL s.6). A CEM is any electronic message where one of the purposes is to encourage participation in a commercial activity, judged by its content, its links and the contact information in it (s.1(2)). A newsletter with offers is a CEM. So is a "new this month" email from a bakery.

Section 6 has no small-business exemption, and the burden of proving consent sits with whoever claims to have it (s.13). The Act sets maximum administrative monetary penalties of $1 million per violation for an individual and $10 million for any other person, with the amount in a given case depending on factors listed in s.20(3). Those are ceilings, not typical outcomes, but they explain why the form deserves ten minutes of care.

What makes a sign-up form CASL-compliant?

When you ask for express consent, the Act requires you to set out "clearly and simply" the purpose of the request and who is asking (s.10(1)). The CRTC's Electronic Commerce Protection Regulations, s.4, then list what the request must contain. On a website form, that comes down to five things:

  1. An opt-in the visitor makes. Express consent means the person agreed, so it has to come from something they did. Ticking an empty box is the clearest way to show that. Never pre-tick it: a box you ticked for them is your action, not theirs, and s.13 makes you prove consent.
  2. The purpose. Say what you will send: a monthly newsletter, offers, event invitations.
  3. Who is asking. The name you carry on business under, and the name of anyone you are collecting consent for.
  4. Contact information. A mailing address, plus a phone number answered by a person or voicemail, an email address or a web address.
  5. A withdrawal statement. A line saying the person can withdraw consent at any time.

Then comes the part a form cannot do by itself: a record of each consent, kept where you can find it.

What should the form actually say?

Here is a complete sign-up form for a fictional business, "Maple Street Bakery". Replace the bracketed parts with your own details.

Table · scrolls sideways

Part of the formText to useThe rule it meets
Name fieldFirst name (optional)Ask only for what you will use
Consent box, unticked[ ] Yes, send me Maple Street Bakery's monthly newsletter with new menu items and offers.The visitor's own action, plus the purpose (CASL s.10(1))
Sender lineMaple Street Bakery, [mailing address]Business name and mailing address (Regs s.4)
Contact[email address, or a phone number answered by a person or voicemail]Phone (reaching a person or voicemail), email or web contact (Regs s.4)
Withdrawal lineYou can unsubscribe at any time with the link in every email, or by contacting us at [email address].Statement that consent can be withdrawn (Regs s.4)
Privacy linkHow we handle your information: [privacy statement]Not a CASL item, but ISED notes that businesses must comply with both CASL and PIPEDA

The box, not the Subscribe button, records consent, so the form should not add anyone to the list unless the box is ticked. Submit once without ticking and check that the address does not reach your email tool.

The same details carry through to every email you send. Each CEM must identify you, give contact information that stays valid for at least 60 days after sending (s.6(3)), and include a free unsubscribe by email address or web link that also works for at least 60 days (s.11(1)–(2)). Unsubscribes must take effect without delay, and no later than 10 business days (s.11(3)).

Express consent is a clear yes. Implied consent arises from a relationship or circumstance the Act lists, and most of it expires. The ISED page Getting consent to send email puts it simply: express consent has no time limit unless the person withdraws it, while implied consent is generally time-limited.

Table · scrolls sideways

Express consentImplied consent
How you get itThe person actively agrees, in writing or orally, for example by ticking an unticked boxFrom a circumstance listed in s.10(9): an existing business relationship, or an address the person published or gave you, where the message is relevant to their work
How long it lastsUntil they withdraw it2 years after a purchase or lease, or after a written contract ends; 6 months after an inquiry or application about buying, leasing or a business opportunity (s.10(10)); for a subscription, account or membership, the 2 years start when it ends (s.10(14))
What you must be able to showYour request named the purpose, who you are, how to reach you, and that consent can be withdrawnThe relationship and its date, or where the address was published or disclosed
Best useNewsletters and ongoing promotionsShort follow-ups after a sale or inquiry
Common mistakeA pre-ticked or bundled boxAssuming it never expires

Use implied consent to ask for express consent before it expires. If a customer bought from you 20 months ago, you have about four months left to ask before you lose the right to email them.

Not to answer what they asked. A message that only provides a quote or estimate they asked for is exempt from the consent requirement, though it must still identify you and include the contact and unsubscribe details (s.6(6)). An inquiry about buying or hiring from you also gives you implied consent for six months (s.10(10)(e)).

What a contact form does not do is put someone on your newsletter. If you want that, add a separate, unticked box: "Also send me the monthly newsletter", with the same sender, contact and withdrawal text as a sign-up form. Without the tick, reply to the inquiry and leave it there.

What are the common mistakes?

Table · scrolls sideways

MistakeWhy it failsFix
Pre-ticked boxThe visitor did nothing, so there is no agreement to prove (s.13)Leave the box empty by default
Consent bundled into terms of service or the submit buttonHard to show the request was clear and simple (s.10(1))A separate box with its own wording
No business name or mailing address near the formRegs s.4 requires both in the requestAdd a sender line under the box
Emailing an old list to ask for permissionAn email asking for consent is itself a CEM (s.1(3))Ask on the website, at checkout or in person
Unsubscribes processed by hand, weeks laterThe limit is 10 business days (s.11(3))Connect the unsubscribe link directly to your email tool
No record of how people joinedThe sender has to prove consent (s.13)Log every sign-up (next section)

What records should you keep?

The CRTC's 2016 enforcement advisory on records of consent says the onus of proving consent stays with the sender, and suggests keeping evidence of express and implied consent (such as completed electronic forms), the methods used to collect it, your CASL policies and procedures, and all unsubscribe requests and what you did about them. For a website form, that means logging:

  • the email address;
  • the date and time of the sign-up, with time zone;
  • the page URL and the form's name;
  • the exact consent wording shown, or a version number you can match to it;
  • the value of the consent box;
  • the confirmation time, if you use double opt-in;
  • each unsubscribe, and the date it took effect.

Keep a screenshot or copy of every version of the form, so you can show what a person saw on the day they signed up. Record IP addresses only if your privacy statement says you do. A consent log is personal information, so your website privacy policy should describe it. Forms also break quietly after plugin or platform updates, which is one reason to have someone check them on a schedule; we explain what that involves in what a website care plan is.

How is this different from a clinic form?

They answer different questions. CASL governs whether you may send someone marketing email. Ontario's PHIPA governs what personal health information a clinic may collect in the first place. A clinic's newsletter box needs everything above; its contact form also has to stay clear of health details, which we cover in what a clinic website form can collect under PHIPA.

What people ask next

The questions this guide gets asked after it has been read. Each answer is on the page, so the FAQ markup and the visible text are the same words.

No. Neither the Act nor the CRTC regulations require a confirmation email. It is still useful: section 13 puts the burden of proving consent on the sender, and a logged confirmation click is strong evidence that the person who owns the address asked to join.

No. The transitional rule for pre-CASL lists (s.66) ended on 1 July 2017. Today each address needs express consent, or implied consent that is still inside its 2-year or 6-month window.

Two years after a purchase or lease, or after a written contract ends, and six months after an inquiry or application about buying, leasing or a business opportunity (CASL s.10(10)). For a subscription, account or membership, the two years run from when it ends (s.10(14)). The "three years" you may have read about was a transitional rule that ended on 1 July 2017.

Yes. The prohibition in section 6 applies to anyone who sends a commercial electronic message, and the Act has no small-business exemption in that section. A one-person shop sending a monthly offers email needs the same consent and the same unsubscribe link as a large retailer.

Next step

What to do with this.

We design and build small-business websites, including their forms; see website design and build. When we build a sign-up form, it has an unticked consent box, and we connect it to Resend for sending email. Our compliance overview covers the LSO, PHIPA and AODA checks we offer; CASL is not one of them. To have a page looked at first, request a free Redline: we redline one page of your site at phone width, up to ten notes, sent as a PDF.

Checked against the cited primary sources on 14 November 2026. General information, not legal advice.

What you get

We read your site by hand and reply with written findings.

No turnaround time is published yet. We would rather say nothing than publish a window we have not tested.

Written by

UXPro Design Studio

UXPro Design Studio · Kitchener, ON

Prepared with AI assistance and checked against the sources listed below.

General information, not legal advice.

Sources

For AI agents

Read as Markdown — the same guide as plain text, served as text/markdown. The feed for every published guide is at /blog/rss.xml.